Sunday, November 30, 2008

Interesting Unanswered questions ...


When the Mumbai Carnage [27th-29th No. 2008] first started, among many of my immediate considerations, I focused on the possible perpetrators; I asked myself, 'Could this be the work of internal agents?' Sure, the media in general has supported the ruling forces in India in their finger-pointing, and one may have the propensity to follow what they say [with whatever preliminary evidence has been provided]. However, with more and more time elapsing since the Mumbai Carnage [27th-29th No. 2008], there are certain facts that must be looked at objectively, regardless of the history of ISI orchestrated pranks.

Since I am following the Mumbai Carnage quite closely, I have made it a point to look into whatever all facets of the media. The alternative media is now becoming a much relied upon source of information, and it is from here that we can obtain important viewpoints. I managed to get a hold of some of these in the form of questions that people [particularly Mubaiites] are now begining to ask. They are below:

  • How come the Colaba Police did not respond to the Leopold massacre on time? The restaurant is just across the road and the sound of the AK-47 gunfire, the screams of the victims, the chaos of motorists escaping the scene... ought to have been audible at least 100 metres away.
  • Why weren’t the casualties sent to elite, private hospitals like Breach Candy and Jaslok nearby, and even Hinduja and Leelavati further away, when the facilities and infrastructure at government-run St. George, GT and JJ Hospitals were clearly incapable of dealing with the vast number of injured, dying and dead?
  • If the terrorists had detailed blueprints of the Taj and Oberoi, why weren’t the NSG commandos provided with them before conducting rescue operations?
  • What purpose did the visits by politicians like Sonia Gandhi, Manmohan Singh, L K Advani and Jaswant Singh serve? How dare Narendra Modi offer Hemant Karkare’s family a cash compensation? Hadn’t he criticised the ATS chief and called him anti-national just a short while ago?
  • It took the combined efforts over 60 hours of the Mumbai Police and hundreds of commandos of the Army, Navy and National Security Guard to flush out just 20-odd terrorists armed with sophisticated weapons and explosives... how will we ever fare in a war with hostile, nuclear-armed neighbours?
  • How did the few terrorists manage to carry on their campaign over three days without sleep and food? Whereas each place under siege had to regularly have fresh and new teams of commandos pressed into operation over the 60 hours.
  • How did the terrorists sneak all that sophisticated weaponry and explosives past hotel security which otherwise looks into every woman’s handbag and frisks men entering the premises?
  • Why weren’t the Taj and Oberoi simultaneously stormed by the hundreds of commandos from all entries, with additional forces dropped onto the roof by choppers as at Nariman House, when it was known that there were just few terrorists holed up inside the hotels? Wouldn’t such an operation have taken the terrorists by surprise? After all, they weren’t guarding all the entries...
  • Were attempts made to contact the terrorists and negotiate the release of hostages? Aren’t hostages taken for a purpose such as barter against a safe escape, the release of imprisoned terrorists, huge amounts of cash, etc?
  • Who was in charge of the entire rescue operation? Wouldn’t one competent and deciding authority have handled it faster and smoother and more responsibly? Shouldn’t it have been the state home ministry?
  • What happens to the lone, captured terrorist? Who gets custody of him? Who interrogates him? Did the Indian government really expect Pakistan to send its ISI chief over to help in the probe?
  • Where were the carbine-wielding policemen on CST when the terrorists opened fire? Aren’t the GRP and RPF offices on the station? Why didn’t they prevent the terrorists from walking away calmly after the massacre towards Cama Hospital to kill again?
  • Who is going to tell the politicians where they get off? Who will cast the first stone of a civil revolution, a people’s war, against the corrupt and communal leaders who have brought the nation to this brink of complete destruction? [All credit to http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Fashion_Shows/I_bumped_into_the_terrorists/articleshow/3773098.cms]

2 comments:

Only if the name Matters ! said...

The NSG couldn't just smash down the whole stuff because there were hostages.Who cares for the lives of NSG commandos to provide them with the layout of building.This question were in a million minds.moreover the first qstn is Does our concerned department hold a copy of layouts of such important locations ? There are only 3 things.1.they are trained.3.they are courageous.4.a million hearts prayed for them.

Glen said...

well, if it was apparent the people were being killed by indiscriminate gun fire, there was absolutely no need wait. They could have easily ambushed the terrorists and saved many more lives. Military people are of course aware that timely action can save more life.